Three Criteria the Early Church Used to Recognize New Testament Scripture

Rick
Rick
Last updated 


The Three Criteria Early Christians Used to Recognize Scripture
How the Early Church Recognized the Books of the New Testament
The Historical Criteria for Recognizing New Testament Canon
How the Early Church Determined Which Books Belonged in the New Testament

UNDERGROUND NEWS NETWORK: NEW TESTAMENT SCRIPTURE RECOGNITION - BIBLE RELIABILITY - LIBRARY OF RICKANDRIA


Early Christians did not choose the New Testament books randomly.

Over the first few centuries, church leaders compared many writings and gradually recognized those that carried true apostolic authority.

Three widely acknowledged criteria guided this process.

John 16:13 (KJV)

“Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth…”

1️⃣ Apostolic Authority


The most important test was connection to the apostles.

Apostolic Authority

A book needed to be written by:

an apostle, or

a close companion of an apostle.

Examples:

Book | Apostolic Connection

Matthew | Apostle Matthew
John | Apostle John
Romans | Apostle Paul
Mark | companion of Peter
Luke–Acts | companion of Paul

Books that lacked clear apostolic authorship were usually rejected.

For example:

  • Shepherd of Hermas
  • Didache

These writings were respected but written too late to come from the apostles.

External sources:

2️⃣ Orthodox Teaching (Agreement with Apostolic Doctrine)


The second criterion was doctrinal consistency.

Orthodox Teaching

The early church asked:

Does the book agree with the teachings already received from the apostles?

Galatians 1:8 (KJV)

“But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you… let him be accursed.”

Books that promoted strange doctrines were rejected.

Examples:

  • Gospel of Thomas
  • Gospel of Peter

Some of these writings reflected Gnostic beliefs, which contradicted the apostolic message about Christ.

External sources:

3️⃣ Widespread Acceptance in the Churches


The third criterion was universal usage among Christian communities.

Catholicity of Scripture

If a book was:

  • read in worship
  • copied by many churches
  • accepted across regions

it gained strong support as Scripture.

Books recognized across the Christian world included:

  • the four Gospels
  • Acts
  • the letters of Paul

But some writings were only used locally, which weakened their claim to canonical status.

For example:

  • Apocalypse of Peter
  • Epistle of Barnabas

External sources:

How these criteria shaped the New Testament


By the 4th century, church leaders widely recognized the same 27 books that appear in modern New Testaments.

A famous list comes from Athanasius of Alexandria, whose Festal Letter (AD 367) lists the complete New Testament canon.

External reference:

Why these standards mattered


The early church was surrounded by many writings about Jesus.

Without careful discernment, confusion could have spread easily.

But these criteria helped believers identify writings that faithfully preserved the apostolic testimony.

2 Peter 1:21 (KJV)

“Holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost.”

Here at the Underground News Network, we can also show you something fascinating:

The 10 most famous “lost gospels” people claim were removed from the Bible — and why historians know they were never actually part of the New Testament canon.